Storm Damage? We Can Help! Learn More About Our Emergency Storm Services & Call Now For Relief.

South MS: (601) 520-3183

North MS: (662) 636-7663

North AL: (256) 692-5527

Meridian, MS: (601) 841-3218

Do You Need To File An Insurance Claim

Learn How Our Insurance Experts Can Help

Storm Damage? We Can Help! Learn More About Our Emergency Storm Services & Call Now For Relief.

Metal Roof vs. Shingles: Which Roofing Material Should You Choose?

Posted on January 14, 2025

metal roof vs shingles

The first step in protecting your home from damage is choosing the appropriate roofing material, and it’s a crucial choice. The contrast between metal roofs and conventional shingles is increasingly important as homeowners look at long-term value, sustainability, and durability. Knowing the main differences between these options, whether you’re building a new house or replacing an old roof, will help you make a choice you’ll be happy with for years to come.

In this blog post, we’ll get into the differences between a metal roof vs. shingles, so you choose the right option for your home.

What Are Metal Roofs?

Metal Roof
Metal Roof

Strong and adaptable, metal roofing systems are prized for their low maintenance requirements, energy efficiency, and longevity. In addition to being made to endure severe weather, metal can improve a building’s visual appeal. Metal roofs are perfect for both residential and commercial buildings since they are lightweight and resistant to fire and strong winds. 

They are completely recyclable at the end of their useful lives, frequently composed of recycled materials, and overall environmentally friendly. Metal roofs offer a durable, sustainable alternative to conventional solutions like asphalt shingles because of their reflective qualities, which help to reduce heat absorption and lower energy costs.

Types of Metal Roofing Materials

  1. Steel: Strong and durable, often coated with zinc (galvanized) or aluminum-zinc (Galvalume) for corrosion resistance.
  2. Aluminum: Lightweight and corrosion-resistant, ideal for coastal areas with high energy efficiency due to its reflectivity.
  3. Copper: Long-lasting and distinctive, developing a natural patina over time that adds protection.
  4. Zinc: Durable and low-maintenance, forming a self-healing patina for scratch protection.

Types of Metal Roofing Styles

  1. Standing Seam Panels: Vertical panels with raised, interlocking seams provide a sleek and weather-resistant design.
  2. Corrugated Panels: Wavy or ribbed patterns offer durability and cost-effectiveness, making them ideal for industrial and agricultural settings.
  3. Metal Shingles: Designed to mimic asphalt or wood, they combine metal’s durability with aesthetic versatility.
  4. Metal Tiles: Lightweight and durable, these replicate clay or concrete tiles, perfect for Mediterranean or modern styles.
  5. Ribbed Panels: Visible ribs add strength and an industrial look, commonly used in commercial applications.

What Are Asphalt Shingles?

Asphalt Shingle
Asphalt Shingle

Made from a blend of asphalt and fiberglass, asphalt shingles are a popular roofing material with overlapping components that protect against UV rays and water erosion. Their granular surface increases durability by guarding against mildew, algae, and sunlight, extending their lifespan. 

These shingles form a tight seal to minimize leaks and come in a variety of designs and colors, providing appeal for any home. Asphalt shingles have always been a favorite in both residential and commercial buildings for their long-lasting performance, ease of installation, and affordability.

Materials Used in Asphalt Shingles

  1. Fiberglass Mat: Serving as the core of asphalt shingles, the fiberglass mat provides strength and helps prevent tearing, making it a durable choice.
  2. Asphalt Coating: This waterproof layer applied over the mat protects the roof from moisture and harsh weather conditions, ensuring better durability.
  3. Mineral Granules: These granules not only add color but also offer UV protection and help resist algae, contributing to the shingles’ longevity and performance.

Types of Asphalt Shingles

  1. 3-Tab Shingles: Lightweight and budget-friendly, these shingles feature three cutouts for a uniform look, offering basic protection and lasting around 20 years.
  2. Architectural Shingles: Thicker and textured, these shingles add dimension and curb appeal while providing better durability, with a lifespan of up to 30 years.
  3. Luxury Shingles: Designed to mimic high-end materials like slate or wood shakes, these premium shingles offer exceptional durability and aesthetic value, making them a great investment for upscale homes.

Also Read: Best Asphalt Shingle Brands for Your Roof (2025) 

Key Differences Between A Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles

Now that you know what shingle and metal roofs are, let’s get into the main differences between them so you can choose the right roofing option for your home:

1. Cost

When considering roofing options, asphalt shingles are the more budget-friendly choice, typically costing $3 to $5 per square foot. In contrast, metal roofs are more expensive, ranging from $5 to $25 per square foot. While metal roofs come with a higher initial cost, their long-term savings through reduced maintenance and repairs can make them a more valuable investment.

2. Durability

Metal roofs are the clear winner when it comes to metal vs. shingle roof durability. They are highly resistant to fire, rot, and pests, and they perform well in extreme weather conditions such as heavy rain, high winds, and hail. Asphalt shingles, though durable, are more prone to cracking and curling, especially after exposure to harsh weather. This can lead to higher repair costs over time for homeowners.

3. Lifespan   

Their durability is reflected in the lifespan of both materials. Metal roofs last significantly longer, with a lifespan of 40 to 70 years, while asphalt shingles usually last 20 to 30 years. So, for homeowners seeking a long-term investment, shingles vs. a metal roof is an easy choice, as metal roofs are a practical option offering excellent value over time.

4. Maintenance

When it comes to maintenance, metal roofs are a clear winner. They require minimal upkeep and are resistant to weather damage and UV exposure. On the other hand, asphalt shingles need regular inspections for wear and tear. Over time, this can lead to repairs and replacement of individual shingles or sections. Ultimately, metal roofs are easier to maintain, reducing overall maintenance costs.

5. Energy Efficiency

In addition to less maintenance, metal roofs offer significant energy savings. They reflect solar heat, keeping homes cooler and lowering cooling costs by up to 25%. Asphalt shingles, however, can absorb heat, increasing air conditioning bills during warmer months. So when considering a metal roof vs. shingles, metal gives you better cooling benefits.

6. Noise Levels

One downside of metal roofs is that they can be noisier during rain or hail compared to asphalt shingles. However, with proper insulation during roofing installation, this issue can be minimized. Homeowners should take this into account when choosing between a metal roof vs. shingles, considering their local climate and personal preferences for noise levels.

7. Aesthetic Options

Asphalt shingles come in many colors and styles, including options that mimic the look of wood or slate. Meanwhile, metal roofs also come in various colors but may not have the same texture variety as asphalt shingles. Still, metal roofs can provide a modern and attractive look for your home.

8. Installation Complexity

The installation of asphalt shingles is quicker and easier, often leading to lower labor costs. Metal roofs require specialized skills for proper installation, which could raise labor costs. However, proper installation of either material means better performance and a longer lifespan, making it a smart investment in the long run.

9. Weight

Weight is another consideration. Asphalt shingles are generally heavier than some metal roofing options, but they are lighter than materials like clay tiles. Metal roofs are typically lighter than traditional options, which can benefit homes that need a lightweight material to avoid additional structural stress.

10. Resale Value

When it comes to resale value, metal roofs often have an edge. Their durability, longevity, and energy efficiency make them appealing to potential buyers. On the other hand, while asphalt shingles are affordable and commonly used, they don’t provide the same long-term value when it’s time to sell.

11. Fire Resistance

In fire-prone areas, fire resistance is key. Metal roofs are highly fire-resistant and don’t ignite from sparks or embers, unlike asphalt shingles, which vary in fire resistance. While asphalt shingles offer some protection, metal roofs provide superior fire resistance.

12. Weather Resistance

Lastly, in terms of weather resistance, metal roofs perform exceptionally well. Their smooth surfaces help shed debris and rain, reducing the risk of damage. Asphalt shingles can trap moisture, leading to mold growth and deterioration, especially in humid climates or areas with heavy rainfall.

When To Choose Which Material

After understanding the basic differences between both options, here are some tips on when to choose which material under different circumstances:

Choose Metal Roofs If:

1. Durability and Longevity

You want a roofing material that offers long-lasting durability and protects your investment over decades.

2. Extreme Weather Resistance

You live in an area with harsh weather conditions and need a roof that can stand up to rain, hail, and high winds.

3. Energy Efficiency

You’re looking for a roof that keeps your home cooler in the summer and helps reduce energy bills over time.

4. Low Maintenance

You prefer a roof that requires minimal upkeep and stays in good condition with less attention.

5. Fire and Insect Resistance

You want protection from fire, rust, and insect damage, and an overall resilient choice.

Choose Asphalt Shingles If:

1. Budget-Friendly Option

You need a more affordable roofing solution that fits within your budget.

2. Traditional Aesthetic

You prefer a classic look that suits many different home styles and blends in well with your neighborhood.

3. Design Flexibility

You want a variety of design options without breaking the bank, from colors to styles.

4. Quick Installation

You need a roof installed quickly with minimal disruption to your daily life.

5. Local Availability and Expertise

You want a material that is easy to find, with contractors who are experienced in installation and repair.

Choose the Right Option for Your Roof with B & A Roofing and Gutters

In short, both metal roofs and asphalt shingles have their pros and cons. Metal roofs are more durable, energy-efficient, and long-lasting, while asphalt shingles are less expensive and come in many styles. In the end, your decision should depend on your needs, budget, and local weather. Talking to a roofing expert can help you choose the best option for your home.

At B & A Roofing and Gutters, we specialize in expert metal roofing services and shingle roofing services, including installation and repair. Whether you’re after the long-lasting durability of metal or the affordable, classic appeal of shingles, we’ve got you covered. Our experienced team is here to guide you through the process and ensure a flawless installation. Reach out to us at (601) 520-3183, and let us help you find the perfect roofing solution for your home.

Don’t see your location? Call us! We Likelt serve your area too